Visit MikeHolt.com
Cord-and-Plug Connected Equipment – and the Inspector  

 
Image

We were recently contacted by an electrician that needed Mike’s help and expertise. All identifying names have been removed in an effort to avoid any further conflict. We are sharing this story with the hopes of helping someone that may find themselves in a similar situation.


I recently took a call from a customer that was moving his business into a new building and the electrical inspector had placed a temporary operation restriction on a machine we had manufactured/sold to him some years ago. It stated that the equipment was not "Listed" and as such he would have to have it certified by a Third Party Testing Laboratory (NRTL).

Curious, I contacted the inspector inquiring as to the nature of this highly unusual request (it is cord/plug connected equipment). He indicated that he inspects all equipment and appliances (right down to microwaves and toasters) and generically cited NEC as his substantiation. It took about a week’s worth of exchange and the backing of a substantial industry authority (Thank you Mike Holt) to convince this inspector that cord/plug connected equipment was not subject to NEC.

I would like to have thought that would have been the end of the battle, but the inspector then came back citing a state law barring the sale or transfer of Consumer Electrical Products that were not Listed. (Wow,.. really? From a building inspector?) I pointed out that not only was no sale or transfer taking place, but that this very specialized piece of equipment was not subject to any Consumer Electrical Products law that I had ever seen. He did not care and was going to force the inspection anyway. I responded demanding to know the exact text of the statute that was driving this. The arguments that followed stretched on for weeks until it was escalated to the state level and, with my backing, our customer initiated legal action.

Yes, we were eventually successful, but Hindsight being 20/20 our customer would have waited for final inspection before moving his equipment into the building.

 

Thank you again for your support. It was pivotal in my effort to put this issue to rest. If there is ever anything I can do for you in return please do not hesitate to ask.

 

 

Click Here to Post a Comment Click Here to View Comments Click Here to Unsubscribe
 
Image
 
Visit: Exam Preparation | Continuing Education | Code Products | Newsletters | and more
Copyright© Mike Holt Enterprises of Leesburg, Inc. All Rights Reserved This article is protected by United States copyright laws and may not be published without prior written permission.
Mike Holt Enterprises of Leesburg, Inc. 3604 Parkway Blvd. Suite 3 Leesburg, FL 34748
"... as for me and my house, we will serve the Lord" [Joshua 24:15]
Comments
  • What parts of the NEC was this inspector citing to derive authority to inspect anything that is not part of the permanent building structure? I've witnessed testimony a tendency of inspectors to us faulty receptacle testers when inspecting homeowner electrical installations. When the homeowner told me his side of the story, it sounded like the inspector wanted to force the homeowner to get their electrical work checked by a licensed contractor. The homeowner had come to me for advice and assistance in the installation process and I had lent him a tester to enable him to test his work prior to inspection. When the inspector confronted him about an apparent problem with his outlets, the homeowner asked the inspector if he would mind if he checked the same outlet with his tester. When that tester showed everything fine, the inspector had nothing more to say and signed off on the electrical installation. My point, there seems to be evidence of over-reach of authority in both cases. It raises the question of what added benefit or value do electrical inspectors add if the there is no real effort to evaluate an electrical installation or cord energized equipment being electrically safe or not. If they have the authority to inspect work performed by licensed electrical contractors, it seems to me that they should, with that authority, have the knowledge to be able to demonstrate and/or articulate their electrical safety concerns and not just be label inspectors that moves them to red-tag and installation or assembly.

    Karl Mesenbrink  August 29 2015, 11:32 am EDT

Reply to this comment
* Your Name:
   Your name will appear under your comments.

* Your Email:
   Your email address is not displayed.
* Comments:

Email Notification Options:
Notify me when a reply is posted to this comment
Notify me whenever a comment is posted to this newsletter